Zapier Tasks vs Make Credits vs n8n Executions: 12m & 36m TCO Calculator
Slide your monthly triggers, action steps, array loop multiplier, and internal DevOps hourly rate to expose exact task explosions and 36-month savings across four automation architectures.
Configure Triggers, Loop Depth & Team Seats
Every adjustment recalculates 12m/36m TCO, hidden overages, and switching payback days with shareable URL parameters.
Live 12-Month & 36-Month Spend Comparison
Deterministic Cost & Overage Breakdown
| Provider | Base + Usage | Hidden Overages | 12-Month TCO | 36-Month TCO | Payback | Rates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RailwayLowest 36m Self-hosted n8n on 1-click Railway containers with unlimited runs | $72/mo | $0/mo None triggered | $869 | $2,606 | 65d ($1,950) | Pricing → |
| n8n Cloud Zero loop penalty and unlimited team editor seats included | $82/mo | $0/mo None triggered | $984 | $2,952 | 56d ($1,650) | Pricing → |
| Make.com Fastest visual Zapier exit for linear & mid-loop scenarios | $243/mo | $0/mo None triggered | $2,916 | $8,748 | 49d ($1,190) | Pricing → |
Verified rate card date: 2026-11-21 · Full RAG equations in /llms-full.txt.
Audited Cost Equations & Assumptions
Zapier Loop & Action Task Burn Formula
zapier_monthly_tasks = monthly_triggers * (steps_per_run + (loop_items - 1) * max(1, floor(steps_per_run * 0.6)))
5,000 triggers * 5 steps with a 10-item array burns 160,000 Zapier tasks/mo (~$749/mo) vs 5,000 n8n executions ($55/mo).
n8n Self-Hosted True TCO Formula (Including Ops Time)
self_hosted_monthly_usd = container_vps_usd + redis_postgres_usd + (ops_hours_per_month * devops_hourly_usd)
$22 Railway compute + 1.5 hrs * $85/hr = $149.50 true fully loaded monthly cost for 250,000+ unlimited runs.
How an 8-Item CRM Loop Turns a $69 Zapier Plan Into a $680 Monthly Invoice
When an e-commerce store or SaaS billing webhook dispatches an array containing eight invoice line items, Zapier’s Looping utility bills every downstream formatter, lookup, and Slack alert separately for each item. A single customer checkout consumes 40 to 50 billable tasks before any AI enrichment step even fires.
By executing the entire array inside a single Node.js memory batch, n8n Cloud records one execution regardless of loop depth, and self-hosted Railway deployments remove execution meters altogether.
Calculator Methodology Questions
Does the calculator count hidden internal maintenance hours for self-hosted n8n?
Yes. Self-hosted Railway estimates include one-time container setup migration cost ($1,950 modeled) plus incremental queue-worker RAM scaling past 50,000 monthly triggers.